Progressive Renewal Campaign

How I helped Progressive connect with, and keep, their customers.

My Role
Creative Direction | Research
Copywriting | Content Strategy

The Problem

Bills don't build loyalty.

Progressive's renewal emails weren't pulling the opens or clicks the team wanted. So they called HackerAgency.

I partnered with our strategy and account teams to audit every renewal touch, from the 28-day quote to the final bill. We found a program built to process payments, not keep customers. Headlines were functional. Savings, the number one reason people switch insurers, were buried. Each piece tried to thank, sell and collect at once. And the stream gave up one day after a lapse.

The Approach

Position renewal as a way to rekindle the relationship.

Insurance is bought by everyone and felt by almost no one. Customers told us the less they hear from their insurer, the better. Meanwhile, the competition never stops fishing.

So we reframed renewal as a relationship, one renewed in six-month increments.

The Work

Three concepts.
One big test.

With our strategy in place, I led the creative team to develop three potential directions.

  • Value Town made saving a habit, not a one-time price. "Stay put. Save happy."

  • Competitive Love flipped the competition's bait. They try to buy your love. We show it.

  • Super Benefits surfaced the perks customers never knew they had. "Get more extras than you can shake a stick shift at."

Value Town Concept Adlob

Competitive Love Concept Adlob

Super Benefits Concept Adlob

When the client wants to test everything,
you build everything.

Progressive wanted to test all three concepts in the market. So we chose three emails to redesign—each one built out three different ways with each concept.

Value Town

Opportunities to save are always there, but the customer doesn’t always know about them. The Value Town concept showed them how to spend less without losing coverage.

Super Benefits

Our research showed customers often didn’t know the full extent of what Progressive offered, so we put the benefits up front and made them feel special.

Competitive Love

We reminded customers they can rely on Progressive when they need them. Providing savings is great, but showing up is even better.

Three more emails—
built to work with any concept.

To round out the renewal campaign, we created three new emails using a concept-agnostic design that worked with all three approaches. These introduced some quick wins. Oddly enough, Progressive hadn’t thought to thank their customers.

As part of the campaign, we developed three direct mail pieces and synchronized the send so they would hit the mailbox at the same time the emails hit the inbox.

Let’s not forget the snail mail.

The Result

The new email program lifted open rates 25% and click-through rates 40%. Customers who used to skim past a bill finally had a reason to open, and a reason to stay.

Finally worth opening.